I'm going to go from 2011 to 2022, since there's no way of really knowing how the '24 and '25 classes are going to fare. I'm sticking to my Rule of Two (years): it takes at least two seasons to start to evaluate a class. I'm going to withhold judgment on the '23s, as well, because a lot of them are still around.
2011:
Floyd Raven: Hit
Darzil Washington: Bust (also dead)
Brandon Alexander: Bust
Drew Kaser: All-American
Chance Nelson: Bust
Mike Evans: Best ever at his position
Tyrell Taylor: Bust
Deshazor Everett: Hit
Johntel Franklin: Bust
Steven Jenkins: Hit
Will Randolph: Bust
Johnny Manziel: GOAT
Ben Compton: Hit
Taylor Bertolet: Hit (though also had some key misses)
Shayvion Hatten: Bust
Shaun Ward: Bust
Howard Matthews: Hit
Donnie Baggs: Hit
Devonta Burns: Hit
Nate Gutekunst: Bust (injuries)
Joe Cheek: Hit
2012
Thomas Johnson: I don’t even know where to begin.
Edmund Ray: Never made it to campus.
Polo Manukainiu: An absolute tragedy. RIP.
Edward Pope: Hit, but never really broke out.
Sabian Holmes: Bust
Derek Walker: Hit
Otis Jacobs: Hit
Germain Ifedi: Hit
Julian Obioha: Hit
Kenneth Marshall: Bust
Trey Williams: Hit
Matt Davis: Bust
Mike Matthews: Hit
Alonzo Williams: Hit
Kimo Tipoti: Bust
Jordan Richmond: Bust
Michael Richardson: Bust (neck injury ended his career)
Tyrone Taylor: Bust
DeVante Harris: Hit
2013
J.J. Gustafson: Bust
Daeshon Hall: Hit
Jordan Mastrogiovanni: Somewhere in between
Tommy Sanders: Hit
Justin Manning: Bust
JaQuay Williams: Bust
Cam Clear: In between
Kameron Miles: Bust
Jeremy Tabuyo: In between
Darian Claiborne: Bust/stupid
Shaan Washington: Hit
Hadrick Walker: In between
Kyrion Parker: Bust
Alex Sezer: Hit
Noel Ellis: Bust
Tavares Garner: Bust
Reggie Chevis: Bust
Brett Wade: Bust
Jordan Points: Bust
Kenny Hill: THE TRILL ONE
Jay Arnold: Hit
Laquvionte Gonzalez: Bust
James White: Bust
Jonathan Wiggins: Bust
Victor Davis: Bust
Ish Wilson: Bust
Joas Aguilar: Bust
Isaiah Golden: Bust/stupid
Kohl Stewart: MLB
Sebastian Larue: Bust
Ricky Seals-Jones: Hit
What a waste of a class.
2014:
Donovan Wilson: Hit
Otaro Alaka: HIt
Zaycoven Henderson: Hit
Frank Iheanacho: Bust
Speedy Noil: Bust
Josh Reynolds: HIt
Avery Gennesy: Hit
Jermain Eluemunor: Hit
Qualen Cunningham: Bust
Myles Garrett: GOAT
Zach Ledwik: Bust
Koda Martin: Hit
Kyle Allen: leaning bust
Jarrett Johnson: Hit
DeShawn Washington: Bust
Armani Watts: Hit
Jamal Jeffery: Bust
Nick Harvey: Pre-injury, hit
Josh Walker: Bust
Cedric Collins: Never played
2015:
Jake Hubenak: I don’t know.
Daylon Mack: Hit
Kendall Bussey: Bust
Dwaine Thomas: Bust
Richard Moore: Bust
Christian Kirk: Hit
Damion Ratley: Hit
Erik McCoy: Hit
Claude George: Hit
Roney Elam: in between
James Lockhart: Bust
Daniel LaCamera: Hit
Landis Durham: Hit
Keaton Sutherland: Hit
Kingsley Keke: Hit
Kemah Siverand: Bust
Kyler Murray: Get out.
Riley Garner: Bust
Justin Evans: Hit
Connor Lanfear: HIt
Deshawn Capers-Smith: Hit
Larry Pryor: Hit
Trevor Elbert: Bust
Justin Dunning: Bust
Jay Bradford: Never played
Jordan Davis: Bust
2016:
Clifford Chattman: Bust
Aaron Hansford: Hit
Quartney Davis: Hit
Nick Starkel: In between
Clyde Chriss: Bust
Ryan McCollum: Hit
Trayveon Williams: Hit
Ikenna Okeke: Bust
Kellen Diesch: Bust
Moses Reynolds: Bust
Justin Madubuike: Hit
Rakeem Boyd: Bust
Alton Robinson: Bust
Kendrick Rogers: In between, but memorable
Colton Prater: Hit
Tyrel Dodson: Hit
Austin Anderson: Bust
Riley Anderson: Bust
Charles Oliver: Bust
Braden Mann: All-American
Travon Fuller: Bust
2017:
Josh Rogers: Bust
Dan Moore: Hit
Micheal Clemons: Hit (and F you, F you, and F YOU)
Anthony Hines: Hit
Jhamon Ausbon: Hit
Buddy Johnson: Hit
Jacob Kibodi: Bust
Ondario Robinson: Bust
Tyree Jackson: Hit
Jayden Peevy: Hit
Jared Hocker: Hit
Hezekiah Jones: Bust. Couldn’t stay healthy
Cam Buckley: Bust
Kellen Mond: Hit
Santino Marchiol: Bust
Camron Horry: Bust
Kendrick Carper: Hit
Keynel McZeal: Bust
Debione Renfro: Hit
Adrian Wolford: Bust
Connor Blumrick: Bust
Derrick Tucker: Bust
Carson Green: Hit
Grayson Reed: Bust
Myles Jones: Hit
Roshauud Paul: Bust
Devin Morris: In between
Speedy Howard: Bust
2018:
Charles Strong: Bust
Vernon Jackson: Bust
Tank Jenkins: Bust
James Foster: Bust
Jashaun Corbin: Bust
Glenn Beal: Bust
Bobby Brown: Hit
Leon O’Neal: Hit
Mo Diallo: Bust
Jace Sternberger: All-American
Jalen Preston: Bust
Caleb Chapman: Bust
Tyree Wilson: Bust
Bart Clement: Bust
Brian Johnson: Bust
Deneric Prince: Bust
Max Wright: Hit
Seth Small: Hit
Jordan Moore: Bust
Cole Blanton: Bust
Montel Parker: Bust
Luke Matthews: Hit
2019:
Chris Russell: Hit
Ainias Smith: Hit
Jalen Wydermyer: Hit
Derick Hunter: Bust
KeShun Brown: Bust
Elijah Blades: Bust
Dylan Wright: Bust
Isaiah Spiller: Hit
Erick Young: Bust
Adarious Jones: Bust
Layden Robinson: Hit
Zach Calzada: Hit for one game
Blake Trainor: in between
Tarian Lee: Bust
Kenyon Green: All-American
DeMarvin Leal: All-American
Baylor Cupp: Bust
Braedon Mowry: Bust
RJ Orebo: Bust
Demani Richardson: Hit
Kam Brown: Bust
Brian Williams: Bust
Caden Davis: Bust
Chase Lane: Bust
2020:
Darvon Hubbard: Bust
McKinnley Jackson: Hit
Edgerrin Cooper: All-American
Brian George: Bust
Antonio Doyle: Bust
Devon Achane: Hit
Donell Harris: Bust
Chris Morris: Bust
Antonio Johnson: Hit
Devin Price: Bust
Haynes King: Bust
Josh Moten: Bust
Dallas Walker: Bust
Aki Ogunbiyi: Bust
Deondre Jackson: Bust
Isaiah Raines: Hit
Moose Muhammad: Decide for yourselves
Blake Smith: Bust
Fadil Diggs: Hit
Jaylon Jones: Hit
Demond Demas: Bust
Smart Chibuzo: Bust
Josh Bankhead: Bust
Jordan Jefferson: Bust
Ernest Crownover: Hit
Kenneth Phillips: Never played
2021:
Jordan Moko: Bust
LJ Johnson: Bust
Jardin Gilbert: Bust
Elijah Jeudy: Bust
Bryce Foster: Early hit, later bust
Tunmise Adeleye: Bust
Shemar Turner: Hit
Remington Strickland: Bust
Yulkeith Brown: Bust
Amari Daniels: Hit
Albert Regis: Hit
Marcus Burris: Bust
Dreyden Norwood: Bust
Tyreek Chappell: Hit
Deuce Fatheree: Hit
Deuce Harmon: In between
Matthew Wykoff: Bust
Fernando Garza: Bust
Jahzion Harris: Bust
Shad Banks: TCU
Eli Stowers: Vandy thanks you
Demetrious Crownover: Hit
Everyone’s favorite class, 2022:
LT Overton: Bust
Jacoby Mathews: Bust
Shemar Stewart: Hit
Denver Harris: Bust
Marquis Groves-Killebrew: Bust
Kam Dewberry: Hit
Jake Johnson: Bust
Enai White: Bust
Anthony Lucas: Bust
Mark Nabou: Hit
Gabe Dindy: Bust
Evan Stewart: Get out.
Le’Veon Moss: Hit
Chris Marshall: Bust
Walter Nolen: Hit, but get out.
Theo Ohrstrom: Hit
Smoke Bouie: Bust
Bryce Anderson: Hit
Ethan Moczulski: Miss
Jadon Scarlett: Bust so far
Ish Harris: Bust
Jarred Kerr: In between
Martrell Harris: Bust
Bobby Taylor: Bust, recruiting coordinator in the making
Noah Thomas: Hit
Conner Weigman: Bust
PJ Williams: Bust
Donovan Green: Bust
Malick Sylla: Bust
2011:
Floyd Raven: Hit
Darzil Washington: Bust (also dead)
Brandon Alexander: Bust
Drew Kaser: All-American
Chance Nelson: Bust
Mike Evans: Best ever at his position
Tyrell Taylor: Bust
Deshazor Everett: Hit
Johntel Franklin: Bust
Steven Jenkins: Hit
Will Randolph: Bust
Johnny Manziel: GOAT
Ben Compton: Hit
Taylor Bertolet: Hit (though also had some key misses)
Shayvion Hatten: Bust
Shaun Ward: Bust
Howard Matthews: Hit
Donnie Baggs: Hit
Devonta Burns: Hit
Nate Gutekunst: Bust (injuries)
Joe Cheek: Hit
2012
Thomas Johnson: I don’t even know where to begin.
Edmund Ray: Never made it to campus.
Polo Manukainiu: An absolute tragedy. RIP.
Edward Pope: Hit, but never really broke out.
Sabian Holmes: Bust
Derek Walker: Hit
Otis Jacobs: Hit
Germain Ifedi: Hit
Julian Obioha: Hit
Kenneth Marshall: Bust
Trey Williams: Hit
Matt Davis: Bust
Mike Matthews: Hit
Alonzo Williams: Hit
Kimo Tipoti: Bust
Jordan Richmond: Bust
Michael Richardson: Bust (neck injury ended his career)
Tyrone Taylor: Bust
DeVante Harris: Hit
2013
J.J. Gustafson: Bust
Daeshon Hall: Hit
Jordan Mastrogiovanni: Somewhere in between
Tommy Sanders: Hit
Justin Manning: Bust
JaQuay Williams: Bust
Cam Clear: In between
Kameron Miles: Bust
Jeremy Tabuyo: In between
Darian Claiborne: Bust/stupid
Shaan Washington: Hit
Hadrick Walker: In between
Kyrion Parker: Bust
Alex Sezer: Hit
Noel Ellis: Bust
Tavares Garner: Bust
Reggie Chevis: Bust
Brett Wade: Bust
Jordan Points: Bust
Kenny Hill: THE TRILL ONE
Jay Arnold: Hit
Laquvionte Gonzalez: Bust
James White: Bust
Jonathan Wiggins: Bust
Victor Davis: Bust
Ish Wilson: Bust
Joas Aguilar: Bust
Isaiah Golden: Bust/stupid
Kohl Stewart: MLB
Sebastian Larue: Bust
Ricky Seals-Jones: Hit
What a waste of a class.
2014:
Donovan Wilson: Hit
Otaro Alaka: HIt
Zaycoven Henderson: Hit
Frank Iheanacho: Bust
Speedy Noil: Bust
Josh Reynolds: HIt
Avery Gennesy: Hit
Jermain Eluemunor: Hit
Qualen Cunningham: Bust
Myles Garrett: GOAT
Zach Ledwik: Bust
Koda Martin: Hit
Kyle Allen: leaning bust
Jarrett Johnson: Hit
DeShawn Washington: Bust
Armani Watts: Hit
Jamal Jeffery: Bust
Nick Harvey: Pre-injury, hit
Josh Walker: Bust
Cedric Collins: Never played
2015:
Jake Hubenak: I don’t know.
Daylon Mack: Hit
Kendall Bussey: Bust
Dwaine Thomas: Bust
Richard Moore: Bust
Christian Kirk: Hit
Damion Ratley: Hit
Erik McCoy: Hit
Claude George: Hit
Roney Elam: in between
James Lockhart: Bust
Daniel LaCamera: Hit
Landis Durham: Hit
Keaton Sutherland: Hit
Kingsley Keke: Hit
Kemah Siverand: Bust
Kyler Murray: Get out.
Riley Garner: Bust
Justin Evans: Hit
Connor Lanfear: HIt
Deshawn Capers-Smith: Hit
Larry Pryor: Hit
Trevor Elbert: Bust
Justin Dunning: Bust
Jay Bradford: Never played
Jordan Davis: Bust
2016:
Clifford Chattman: Bust
Aaron Hansford: Hit
Quartney Davis: Hit
Nick Starkel: In between
Clyde Chriss: Bust
Ryan McCollum: Hit
Trayveon Williams: Hit
Ikenna Okeke: Bust
Kellen Diesch: Bust
Moses Reynolds: Bust
Justin Madubuike: Hit
Rakeem Boyd: Bust
Alton Robinson: Bust
Kendrick Rogers: In between, but memorable
Colton Prater: Hit
Tyrel Dodson: Hit
Austin Anderson: Bust
Riley Anderson: Bust
Charles Oliver: Bust
Braden Mann: All-American
Travon Fuller: Bust
2017:
Josh Rogers: Bust
Dan Moore: Hit
Micheal Clemons: Hit (and F you, F you, and F YOU)
Anthony Hines: Hit
Jhamon Ausbon: Hit
Buddy Johnson: Hit
Jacob Kibodi: Bust
Ondario Robinson: Bust
Tyree Jackson: Hit
Jayden Peevy: Hit
Jared Hocker: Hit
Hezekiah Jones: Bust. Couldn’t stay healthy
Cam Buckley: Bust
Kellen Mond: Hit
Santino Marchiol: Bust
Camron Horry: Bust
Kendrick Carper: Hit
Keynel McZeal: Bust
Debione Renfro: Hit
Adrian Wolford: Bust
Connor Blumrick: Bust
Derrick Tucker: Bust
Carson Green: Hit
Grayson Reed: Bust
Myles Jones: Hit
Roshauud Paul: Bust
Devin Morris: In between
Speedy Howard: Bust
2018:
Charles Strong: Bust
Vernon Jackson: Bust
Tank Jenkins: Bust
James Foster: Bust
Jashaun Corbin: Bust
Glenn Beal: Bust
Bobby Brown: Hit
Leon O’Neal: Hit
Mo Diallo: Bust
Jace Sternberger: All-American
Jalen Preston: Bust
Caleb Chapman: Bust
Tyree Wilson: Bust
Bart Clement: Bust
Brian Johnson: Bust
Deneric Prince: Bust
Max Wright: Hit
Seth Small: Hit
Jordan Moore: Bust
Cole Blanton: Bust
Montel Parker: Bust
Luke Matthews: Hit
2019:
Chris Russell: Hit
Ainias Smith: Hit
Jalen Wydermyer: Hit
Derick Hunter: Bust
KeShun Brown: Bust
Elijah Blades: Bust
Dylan Wright: Bust
Isaiah Spiller: Hit
Erick Young: Bust
Adarious Jones: Bust
Layden Robinson: Hit
Zach Calzada: Hit for one game
Blake Trainor: in between
Tarian Lee: Bust
Kenyon Green: All-American
DeMarvin Leal: All-American
Baylor Cupp: Bust
Braedon Mowry: Bust
RJ Orebo: Bust
Demani Richardson: Hit
Kam Brown: Bust
Brian Williams: Bust
Caden Davis: Bust
Chase Lane: Bust
2020:
Darvon Hubbard: Bust
McKinnley Jackson: Hit
Edgerrin Cooper: All-American
Brian George: Bust
Antonio Doyle: Bust
Devon Achane: Hit
Donell Harris: Bust
Chris Morris: Bust
Antonio Johnson: Hit
Devin Price: Bust
Haynes King: Bust
Josh Moten: Bust
Dallas Walker: Bust
Aki Ogunbiyi: Bust
Deondre Jackson: Bust
Isaiah Raines: Hit
Moose Muhammad: Decide for yourselves
Blake Smith: Bust
Fadil Diggs: Hit
Jaylon Jones: Hit
Demond Demas: Bust
Smart Chibuzo: Bust
Josh Bankhead: Bust
Jordan Jefferson: Bust
Ernest Crownover: Hit
Kenneth Phillips: Never played
2021:
Jordan Moko: Bust
LJ Johnson: Bust
Jardin Gilbert: Bust
Elijah Jeudy: Bust
Bryce Foster: Early hit, later bust
Tunmise Adeleye: Bust
Shemar Turner: Hit
Remington Strickland: Bust
Yulkeith Brown: Bust
Amari Daniels: Hit
Albert Regis: Hit
Marcus Burris: Bust
Dreyden Norwood: Bust
Tyreek Chappell: Hit
Deuce Fatheree: Hit
Deuce Harmon: In between
Matthew Wykoff: Bust
Fernando Garza: Bust
Jahzion Harris: Bust
Shad Banks: TCU
Eli Stowers: Vandy thanks you
Demetrious Crownover: Hit
Everyone’s favorite class, 2022:
LT Overton: Bust
Jacoby Mathews: Bust
Shemar Stewart: Hit
Denver Harris: Bust
Marquis Groves-Killebrew: Bust
Kam Dewberry: Hit
Jake Johnson: Bust
Enai White: Bust
Anthony Lucas: Bust
Mark Nabou: Hit
Gabe Dindy: Bust
Evan Stewart: Get out.
Le’Veon Moss: Hit
Chris Marshall: Bust
Walter Nolen: Hit, but get out.
Theo Ohrstrom: Hit
Smoke Bouie: Bust
Bryce Anderson: Hit
Ethan Moczulski: Miss
Jadon Scarlett: Bust so far
Ish Harris: Bust
Jarred Kerr: In between
Martrell Harris: Bust
Bobby Taylor: Bust, recruiting coordinator in the making
Noah Thomas: Hit
Conner Weigman: Bust
PJ Williams: Bust
Donovan Green: Bust
Malick Sylla: Bust
